Another key issue in this situation is whether the victim was willing to voluntarily seek out treatment. If the victim is incapable of saying no, he or she is deemed incapable of consenting to treatment. If the victim is willing to do so, however, the court will find that the consent of the victim is valid and the defendant is legally liable for the proposed treatment.
In order to make the best use of your time during your review of this case study, you need to be able to understand the assessment thoroughly. In this way, you will have the opportunity to understand how the case study has been handled through the analysis and will be able to respond accordingly.
One of the first things that you should focus on is to identify the type of plan that the victim was offered. This will help you analyze the entire plan, both structurally and functionally.
You also need to look at the components of the proposed plan. For example, was the plan designed to put the patient in a position where he or she was likely to be unable to say no?
The other thing that you need to consider is how well the plan addressed the alternatives presented by the situation. For example, did the plan include a mechanism to get the patient to sign a form that allows for discontinuation of the treatment plan if the patient were to withdraw from it?
Was the plan structured in such a way that the patient knew what to expect as he or she approached the procedure? Were the specifics of the plan and the “opt-out” page explained clearly to the patient?
In a case such as this, if the plan did not contain these elements, the physician’s interpretation of the child’s decision to take part in the proposed treatment plan may not have been informed consent procedure. As a result, the judge may find that the child did not give his or her informed consent.
Next, you need to analyze whether the pediatric consent case study was an elaborate care plan or a simply an attempt to bring a minor into the courtroom. If the latter, then you need to know the details of how it was organized, and why it was structured that way.
Did the plan involve a physical examination, an accurate assessment of the symptoms, the planned medications, and any follow-up care? Or was it a simple written consent for the parents to submit for filing?
After all this analysis, you can see that there are many steps that make up a good case study analysis. It is important to carefully consider all of the elements, and ask yourself whether or not the plan is structured in a way that it meets all the legal requirements for conducting this type of investigation.
The goal of this case study analysis is to give you the insight you need to figure out what to expect when you go before a judge. With these tips, you should be able to handle it confidently.